computers will always be computers
Wednesday, May 10th, 2006 by StevenThere is no doubt in my mind that computers will eventually pass the Turing test in all fields. However, I believe that computers will never be able to “think” and thus, I tend to agree with John Searle that computers “merely manipulate symbols whereas a brain attaches meaning to them.” Just because a computer is able to exactly imitate the exact processes and produce the exact results that humans produce in a certain situation does not mean that the computer understands what it is doing. It is simply following complex code. Sure, some day in the future, we will have a program that encompasses all aspects of the human mind and install that program into a computer, which will then act human like. But, I’m pretty sure it won’t know what it’s doing because it has no consciousness. Once again, it is just following a set of complex codes and manipulating symbols, which, I think, is the main argument against the possibility that computers will ever possess consciousness. Granted, we don’t know what consciousness is, but a computer is not aware of what it is doing. I feel like my argument is very cyclical, unfulfilling, and feeling-oriented; perhaps, it is because I believe that humans are special as Brooks would say. Nevertheless, I still believe that computers will always be computers and nothing more.
If one looks at human behavior, one will notice that we are pretty arbitrary in similar, if not identical situations. Now, I question whether or not a computer will have the ability to be arbitrary. Suppose one day that Bob walks into a room covered with red wallpaper and suddenly feels angry; the next day, Bob (his current mood prior to walking into the room is the same as it was during the first day) walks into the same room with red wallpaper and suddenly feels even angrier. Would a computer have this notion of arbitrariness? I tend to think that it would not as it would feel the same level of “angry” after both visits into the room.
My conclusion about AI is: computers someday will have the ability to accurately imitate humans in almost every situation, which will be freaky. There is still a long way to go since humans still do not understand many aspects of themselves that are being imitated.